Can You Sue A Towing Company? Practical Guide To Your Rights
Understand your rights, common towing company violations, and the practical steps to seek compensation when a tow goes wrong.
Towing disputes are frustrating. Vehicles may be taken without clear notice, damaged while being moved, or held until you pay fees that feel excessive. In many situations, you can challenge a towing company and, if necessary, sue for compensation. This guide explains your rights, common legal theories, and the steps to take if you believe a towing company acted illegally or carelessly.
Understanding Your Legal Relationship With a Towing Company
Even if you never signed a written contract, the law often treats the towing company as having special responsibilities when it takes your vehicle into its care.
- Implied agreement (bailment): When a tow company takes possession of your car, it generally becomes a bailee and must use reasonable care to protect it from damage or loss.
- Duty to follow towing and consumer laws: States and cities regulate when, where, and how vehicles may be towed, how owners must be notified, and how much and how quickly fees can be charged.
- Obligation to act reasonably on the road: Tow truck drivers must follow ordinary traffic and safety rules; unsafe towing can lead to liability if it causes accidents or damage.
If a towing company violates any of these duties, you may have grounds to demand payment, a refund, or return of your vehicle and its contents.
Common Reasons to Sue a Towing Company
Not every unpleasant tow is illegal. However, certain patterns of behavior frequently lead to valid claims.
1. Illegal or Wrongful Towing
You may have a claim if your car was towed in violation of state or local laws. Examples include:
- Towing from private property without required warning signs, markings, or permissions.
- Towing too quickly after you parked, when a waiting period is required.
- Towing from a legal space, or where restrictions were not clearly posted.
- Police-directed tows conducted in violation of applicable regulations or departmental policies.
The Future of AI: Preventing a Big Tech Monopoly >
Many states and cities require clear signs stating that unauthorized vehicles may be towed, identify the towing company, and list basic fees and contact details. If those requirements are ignored, a tow may be considered improper.
2. Damage to Your Vehicle or Its Contents
Physical damage during towing or storage is one of the most common disputes. You may be able to sue if:
- The vehicle was scratched, dented, or structurally damaged during hookup, loading, or transport.
- Parts such as bumpers, wheels, or mirrors were broken or bent while the car was in the company’s custody.
- Items inside the car (tools, electronics, personal property) went missing or were damaged while the vehicle was stored.
Because the towing company is holding your vehicle under a bailment, they generally must show they used reasonable care. If they cannot, they may be responsible for the loss.
3. Excessive or Unfair Fees and Billing Disputes
Another frequent conflict involves the amount the towing company charges. Concerns may include:
- Daily storage fees that appear unreasonable for the area.
- Multiple or unexplained administrative charges.
- Refusal to release the vehicle unless all disputed amounts are paid in full.
Some states have enacted specific laws to address these disputes. For example, Ohio’s “towing fairness” law lets vehicle owners bring a civil action to challenge excessive towing and storage invoices and recover vehicles or contents. Your state may offer similar protections.
4. Improper Sale or Disposal of Your Vehicle
When vehicles remain unclaimed, towing companies often have the right to sell them to recoup towing and storage fees. However, they must follow procedures set by state law, such as:
- Sending written notice to the registered owner and lienholders within a specified time.
- Providing a clear opportunity to reclaim the vehicle by paying reasonable charges.
- Conducting a sale through a permitted method, such as a public auction, and documenting it properly.
If the company sells your vehicle without proper notice or fails to follow statutory procedures, you may sue for the value of the vehicle and any resulting losses.
Legal Theories Commonly Used Against Towing Companies
Lawyers use different legal theories depending on what happened. You do not have to use legal terminology when you first complain, but understanding these theories helps you see how a court might view your case.
| Legal Theory | What You Must Generally Show | Typical Situations |
|---|---|---|
| Negligence | The tow company failed to use reasonable care and that failure caused your damage. | Poor loading, careless driving, unsafe parking, or failing to secure the vehicle properly. |
| Breach of bailment | The company received your car or property and did not return it in substantially the same condition. | Damage in storage, vandalism due to poor security, missing items from inside the car. |
| Violation of statute or ordinance | The company failed to comply with towing, notice, fee, or consumer-protection rules, causing loss. | Towing without required signs, not sending notices, overcharging beyond legal caps. |
| Conversion / wrongful taking | Your vehicle or property was taken or sold without lawful basis or in a grossly improper way. | Illegal sale of the vehicle, refusal to return it after lawful charges are paid. |
Evidence You Should Gather Before You Sue
If you are considering legal action, strong documentation can make or break your case. Courts expect you to prove what happened, not just describe it.
- Photos and videos of the location from which you were towed, the condition of the car before and after towing, and any visible damage.
- Receipts and invoices showing towing and storage fees, itemized charges, and payment records.
- Tow and police reports, if your car was removed after an accident or police-ordered impound.
- Notices and letters from the towing company about the tow, storage, or planned sale of the vehicle.
- Witness statements from anyone who saw the tow, the condition of the car, or the signage where you parked.
Act quickly: time limits for challenging a tow or filing a claim can be short, and some states have strict deadlines measured in days or months, not years.
Where and How to Bring a Claim
The right forum depends on the size and complexity of your dispute, and sometimes on specific state rules.
1. Informal Resolution and Administrative Complaints
Before suing, it is often wise to try lower-cost options:
- Contact the towing company in writing and clearly describe the problem, the amount you believe is owed, and the resolution you seek.
- File a complaint with a state or local agency, such as a consumer-protection office, public utilities commission, or transportation department that oversees towing.
- Use any formal dispute procedures that state law provides. For instance, some jurisdictions allow owners to contest towing fees in municipal or county court under specialized procedures.
Government complaint processes can sometimes pressure a company to compromise or correct abusive practices.
2. Small Claims Court
If the amount of your dispute is below the local small claims limit, this court is designed for individuals to represent themselves.
- Typical uses: Seeking the cost of vehicle repairs, reimbursement of towing or storage fees, or the value of missing items.
- Advantages: Lower filing fees, faster hearings, simplified procedures, and no requirement to hire a lawyer.
- Limits: You are usually capped at a maximum dollar amount and cannot request complex court orders beyond money damages.
Procedures vary by state, but you generally file a claim form, pay a filing fee, serve the towing company, and appear at a brief hearing to present evidence.
3. Regular Civil Court
Larger or more complex disputes may belong in a higher court, especially when:
- The loss involves a high-value vehicle or extensive damage.
- The towing company allegedly sold your car unlawfully and you seek its full market value.
- There are significant legal questions, multiple parties, or related injury claims (such as an accident caused by negligent towing).
In these cases, consulting a lawyer is often essential. An attorney can identify all potential legal claims, calculate damages, gather expert evidence, and navigate procedural rules.
What Compensation Can You Seek?
Available remedies depend on what happened and which laws apply, but common categories of damages include:
- Repair costs for damage caused while towing or storing your car.
- Replacement value if your vehicle was wrongfully sold, stripped, or destroyed.
- Reimbursement of illegal or excessive fees, including towing and storage charges collected in violation of law.
- Loss-of-use damages for the time you were without the vehicle, where permitted.
- Value of missing personal property that was in the vehicle while in the company’s custody.
- Court costs and, in some cases, attorney’s fees, if a statute specifically allows fee-shifting for consumer violations.
In rare cases involving extreme or intentional misconduct, courts may also award punitive damages to punish and deter wrongful behavior, if allowed by state law.
State and Local Law: Why Location Matters
Towing disputes are heavily shaped by the law of the state and city where the incident occurred. Differences can include:
- How quickly a vehicle can be sold after a tow if unclaimed.
- What type of notice (mail, posting, electronic) must be given before a sale.
- Maximum towing or storage fees and whether you can contest them before paying.
- Special procedures in municipal or county courts for challenging invoices or recovering vehicles.
- Licensing and operational rules for towing services, such as registration, required disclosures, and reporting to law enforcement.
Because these rules are very jurisdiction-specific, many consumers consult a local lawyer or legal aid office to interpret their rights under local codes and statutes.
Practical Tips Before You Decide to Sue
Lawsuits take time and energy. Before filing, consider these practical steps:
- Evaluate the size of your claim: Compare your likely recovery to court costs, time away from work, and other burdens.
- Preserve all deadlines: Note any short deadlines to contest a tow, challenge a bill, or claim a vehicle before it is sold.
- Get an independent repair estimate for any physical damage.
- Keep all communication in writing or follow up phone calls with written summaries.
- Consider a legal consultation: A short meeting with a consumer or personal injury attorney may clarify your best options and whether a case is worth pursuing.
Frequently Asked Questions About Suing Towing Companies
Q: Is every tow I disagree with grounds for a lawsuit?
A: No. A tow is usually legal if the company follows state and local rules and acts with reasonable care. A lawsuit typically requires a clear legal violation, such as improper notice, excessive fees, or damage caused by negligence.
Q: Can I get my car back if I dispute the bill?
A: In some states, you may be allowed to pay the undisputed portion of the bill and challenge the rest through a special court process, particularly for commercial vehicles. Rules vary widely, so check local law or speak with a lawyer.
Q: What if the towing company already sold my vehicle?
A: You may still be able to sue for the fair market value of the vehicle plus other losses if the sale did not comply with notice or sale procedures required by law. Act quickly, because statutes of limitations and claim deadlines apply.
Q: Do I need a lawyer, or can I handle this myself?
A: For small disputes within small claims limits, many people represent themselves. For high-value vehicles, injury cases, or complex statutory issues, a lawyer can help you identify the best legal theories, calculate damages, and comply with court rules.
Q: Can I sue for emotional distress caused by an illegal tow?
A: Courts are usually reluctant to award damages for stress or inconvenience alone in towing disputes, unless tied to serious misconduct or physical injury. Most successful cases focus on economic losses such as repair costs, fees, or vehicle value.
References
- Can You Sue a Towing Company for Damages? — LegalMatch. 2022-03-15. https://www.legalmatch.com/law-library/article/liability-of-towing-companies.html
- Can You Sue a Towing Company for Illegally Selling Your Vehicle? — Law Office of Wyckoff Nissenbaum (Ayala Law). 2023-06-21. https://www.lawayala.com/can-you-sue-a-towing-company/
- New Ohio Law on Towing Disputes: What Companies Need to Know About HB 403 — Texas Towing Lawyer. 2022-02-10. https://www.texastowinglawyer.com/blog/new-ohio-law-on-towing-disputes-what-companies-need-to-know-about-hb-403
- New Ohio Towing Fairness Law Takes Effect in April — Transport Topics. 2022-01-25. https://www.ttnews.com/articles/ohio-towing-fairness-law
- 4 Tips for Filing a Claim Against a Towing Company — RAK Law Firm. 2023-04-19. https://www.raklawfirm.com/blog/4-tips-for-filing-a-claim-against-a-towing-company/
- Section 4513.67 | Operation of towing service. — Ohio Revised Code, Ohio Legislature. 2021-10-01. https://codes.ohio.gov/ohio-revised-code/section-4513.67
- Can I Sue a Towing Company for Damaging My Car? — Cellino Law. 2021-12-09. https://www.cellinolaw.com/manhattan/car-accident-lawyer/towing-company-damage/
Similar Articles
Read full bio of medha deb
