Understanding the First Step Act: Federal Sentencing and Prison Reform
A clear guide to how the First Step Act changes federal sentencing, prison conditions, and rehabilitation opportunities for incarcerated people.
The First Step Act is a landmark federal law that reshaped parts of the United States criminal justice system, especially for people in federal prisons. It combines changes to sentencing rules with reforms to prison conditions and new incentives designed to reduce reoffending after release. This article explains what the Act does, why it matters, and how it affects incarcerated individuals, their families, and the broader justice system.
What Is the First Step Act?
The First Step Act of 2018, formally enacted as Public Law 115–391, is a bipartisan criminal justice reform law passed by Congress and signed by the President in December 2018. It focuses on the federal system only; it does not directly change state criminal laws, state prison systems, or local jail policies. Instead, it targets federal sentencing rules and conditions inside federal prisons operated by the Bureau of Prisons (BOP).
Broadly, the law seeks to:
- Reduce recidivism through evidence-based rehabilitation programs and incentives.
- Improve prison conditions and protect vulnerable populations such as pregnant people and juveniles.
- Moderate certain federal sentences, especially for nonviolent drug offenses, and expand judicial discretion.
- Trim the federal prison population while maintaining public safety.
Strategies for Collecting Unpaid Child Support >
Core Goals Behind the Law
The First Step Act reflects a shift away from a purely punitive approach toward a more rehabilitative model in the federal system. Policymakers designed the law to address concerns about mass incarceration, long and inflexible sentences, and limited opportunities for people in prison to prepare for life after release.
Key policy goals include:
- Promoting rehabilitation through structured programming, education, and treatment.
- Encouraging accountability by rewarding good behavior and active participation in programs with credits and reduced time in custody.
- Enhancing fairness in sentencing by correcting some earlier laws that produced disproportionate penalties, particularly in drug cases.
- Improving human rights conditions in federal prisons by limiting certain practices and ensuring basic necessities.
Sentencing Reforms: Making Punishments More Proportionate
One of the most visible parts of the First Step Act concerns sentencing reform. The law does not rewrite the entire federal sentencing scheme, but it introduces targeted changes that loosen some mandatory minimums, expand judicial discretion, and retroactively apply earlier reforms.
Shorter Mandatory Minimums for Certain Drug Offenses
Federal drug laws traditionally relied heavily on mandatory minimum sentences, which limited judges’ ability to tailor punishments to individual circumstances. The First Step Act narrows some of these penalties, especially for repeat offenders.
Among the changes:
- For certain high-level drug trafficking offenses, the mandatory minimum tied to one qualifying prior conviction dropped from 20 years to 15 years.
- For people with two or more qualifying prior convictions, the mandatory minimum fell from life without parole to 25 years.
- The type of prior offense that can trigger these enhanced penalties is now limited to more serious drug or violent felonies.
These changes reflect a deliberate effort to reduce exceptionally long sentences for some nonviolent and lower-level drug offenders, while still retaining substantial penalties for serious crimes.
Retroactive Application of the Fair Sentencing Act
The First Step Act also makes the Fair Sentencing Act of 2010 retroactive. The Fair Sentencing Act had previously reduced the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine offenses, which was widely criticized as racially discriminatory and outdated.
By allowing people sentenced under the old crack cocaine rules to seek relief under the newer standard, the First Step Act opened the door for thousands of incarcerated individuals to request sentence reductions. Courts now have authority to revisit certain cases and align them with the revised penalties.
Expanded Safety Valve for Low-Level Offenders
The law also expands the federal safety valve, a provision that lets judges impose sentences below otherwise applicable mandatory minimums for qualifying individuals. Before the Act, safety valve relief was limited to defendants with very minimal criminal history. Under the First Step Act, more people with modest criminal records can qualify for this relief, especially if their offenses are low-level, nonviolent drug crimes.
This change increases judicial flexibility and reduces the risk of disproportionately harsh sentences for individuals who present limited danger to public safety.
Earned Time Credits and Good Time: Incentives for Rehabilitation
Beyond sentencing reform, the First Step Act introduces robust systems of earned time credits and good time credits, rewarding incarcerated people for constructive behavior and participation in rehabilitative programming.
Risk and Needs Assessment System
The law requires the Attorney General and BOP to implement a standardized risk and needs assessment system for all federal prisoners. This tool evaluates each person’s likelihood of reoffending and identifies criminogenic needs—such as substance abuse, educational gaps, or lack of job skills—that can be addressed through targeted programs.
Using this assessment, BOP is expected to:
- Assign individuals to appropriate recidivism-reduction programs and productive activities.
- Track progress over time and adjust programming accordingly.
- Determine eligibility for certain credits and early-release opportunities consistent with public safety.
Earned Time Credits for Programming
The Act created a system of earned time credits for individuals who participate in approved recidivism-reduction programs or productive activities. By engaging in activities like vocational training, education, or treatment programs, eligible prisoners accumulate credits that can be applied toward earlier placement in:
- Home confinement,
- Community supervision, or
- Residential reentry centers.
These credits do not erase a sentence entirely, but they can accelerate transition from secure custody into less restrictive forms of supervision, supporting smoother reentry and reducing time in prison for people who invest in their own rehabilitation.
Expansion of Good Time Credits
In addition to earned time credits, the First Step Act adjusts the rules governing good time credits, which reward ongoing compliance with prison rules. The law clarifies that individuals can earn up to 54 days of good time credit per year of their imposed sentence, rather than per year actually served.
This clarification effectively increases the maximum good time credits many people can earn, allowing them to shorten their time in federal custody through consistent positive behavior.
Prison Conditions and Human Rights Protections
The First Step Act also addresses the environment inside federal prisons. While it does not overhaul every aspect of prison life, it introduces important safeguards for vulnerable populations and improves access to basic necessities.
Key Prison Condition Reforms
Notable provisions include:
- Placement closer to home: When practicable, the BOP is directed to place prisoners as close as possible to their primary residence, generally no more than 500 miles away. This is designed to support family ties and reentry preparation.
- Home confinement for low-risk prisoners: The Act encourages greater use of home confinement for prisoners assessed as low risk, expanding noncustodial options that still maintain supervision.
- Compassionate release: The law lowers age and time-served thresholds and broadens eligibility for compassionate release, including for people with serious medical conditions or terminal illness.
Protection of Pregnant Individuals and Juveniles
The Act includes specific measures aimed at protecting individuals who are pregnant or young.
- Ban on shackling pregnant women: The use of restraints on pregnant inmates in the custody of the BOP or U.S. Marshals is prohibited, except in narrow circumstances.
- Access to menstrual products: BOP must provide tampons and sanitary napkins, free of charge and in sufficient quantity to meet medical needs.
- Limits on juvenile solitary confinement: The Act restricts the use of solitary confinement for juveniles in federal custody, allowing it only as a short-term response to immediate serious risk.
These reforms aim to curb practices widely viewed as harmful or inhumane, signaling a commitment to minimum standards of dignity and care within federal facilities.
How the First Step Act Affects Different Stakeholders
The law’s impact varies across different groups involved in the criminal justice system. The table below summarizes some of the practical effects.
| Stakeholder | Primary Impact of the First Step Act |
|---|---|
| Incarcerated individuals | More opportunities to reduce time in custody through good time and earned credits; access to rehabilitation programs; improved protections for vulnerable groups. |
| Judges | Greater discretion for certain drug offenses through expanded safety valve and retroactive application of Fair Sentencing Act provisions. |
| Families | Potentially earlier reunification due to credits and reduced sentences; more chance of placement closer to home. |
| Bureau of Prisons | New responsibilities to implement risk assessments, manage programming, track credits, and comply with new conditions and protections. |
| Communities | Increased emphasis on rehabilitated individuals returning with more skills and support, with the aim of lowering recidivism and improving public safety. |
Limitations and Ongoing Debates
Although the First Step Act has been widely described as a significant reform, it is not a comprehensive solution to mass incarceration. Its reach is limited to the federal system, which covers a minority of the total incarcerated population in the United States. Most people in prison are held in state facilities governed by state law.
Critics raise several concerns:
- Some argue that the law does not go far enough in reducing mandatory minimums or revisiting past sentences.
- There are questions about how consistently risk assessments and credits are implemented across facilities.
- Legal disputes and later court decisions have affected how certain provisions are interpreted, including eligibility for credits and application of sentencing relief.
Despite these challenges, the First Step Act remains an important case study in bipartisan criminal justice reform, blending sentencing adjustments with rehabilitative incentives and human rights protections.
Practical Tips for Affected Individuals and Families
For people currently in federal custody and their families, understanding the First Step Act can help maximize the law’s potential benefits.
- Request information on programming: Incarcerated individuals should inquire about available recidivism-reduction programs and productive activities that qualify for earned time credits.
- Stay in good standing: Maintaining positive behavior and compliance with institutional rules is key to accumulating good time credits.
- Consult legal counsel: People who believe they may be eligible for sentence reductions—such as those sentenced under older crack cocaine laws—should seek legal advice about possible motions or petitions.
- Monitor policy updates: Implementation guidelines can evolve, so staying informed about BOP policies and federal court decisions can be important.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Does the First Step Act apply to state prisoners?
No. The First Step Act applies to federal criminal cases and federal prisons. State sentencing laws and state prison systems are governed by separate state legislation and policies.
Can the First Step Act completely eliminate a prison sentence?
Generally, no. The Act provides avenues for reducing time in custody—such as earned time credits, expanded good time credits, compassionate release, and retroactive sentencing changes—but it does not erase convictions or guarantee release.
How do prisoners earn time credits?
Eligible individuals earn credits by participating in approved recidivism-reduction programs or productive activities, as identified through the risk and needs assessment system. Credits can later be applied toward early transfer to home confinement, supervised release, or reentry centers.
What types of programs qualify for earned time credits?
Programs typically include vocational training, educational courses, drug treatment, and other evidence-based interventions designed to reduce the likelihood of reoffending. Specific offerings may vary by institution.
Are all prisoners eligible for these credits and reforms?
No. Eligibility depends on factors such as the nature of the offense, risk assessment results, prior criminal history, and statutory exclusions. Some serious violent or high-level offenses may limit eligibility.
How does the Act affect people convicted of crack cocaine offenses before 2010?
The First Step Act makes the Fair Sentencing Act of 2010 retroactive, allowing many individuals sentenced under the older crack cocaine law to petition for sentence reductions under the updated, less severe penalties.
References
- First Step Act — Wikipedia (summary of law and major provisions). 2024-10-21. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Step_Act
- First Step Act Overview — Federal Bureau of Prisons. 2023-06-01. https://www.bop.gov/inmates/fsa/overview.jsp
- First Step Act Earned Time Credits — U.S. Sentencing Commission. 2026-03-16. https://www.ussc.gov/education/first-step-act-earned-time-credits
- S.756 – First Step Act of 2018 — U.S. Congress. 2018-12-21. https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/756
- First Step Act — National Institute of Corrections. 2021-04-15. https://nicic.gov/resources/nic-library/corrections-trends/first-step-act
- The First Step Act: Ending Mass Incarceration in Federal Prisons — The Sentencing Project. 2019-07-01. https://www.sentencingproject.org/policy-brief/the-first-step-act-ending-mass-incarceration-in-federal-prisons/
- Analyzing the First Step Act’s Impact on Criminal Justice — Brennan Center for Justice. 2020-06-01. https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/analyzing-first-step-acts-impact-criminal-justice
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
