Understanding California Insurance Fraud Laws
Learn how California defines, investigates, and punishes insurance fraud across auto, health, workers’ compensation, and other coverage types.
California treats insurance fraud as a serious crime and civil violation, combining criminal statutes, civil penalty provisions, and regulatory requirements aimed at protecting both consumers and insurers. This guide explains how California defines insurance fraud, the types of conduct that can lead to prosecution, potential penalties, and how suspected fraud is investigated and reported.
What Counts as Insurance Fraud in California?
Under California law, insurance fraud covers a wide range of conduct involving the misrepresentation or concealment of facts related to insurance claims, policy applications, and premium calculations. The focus is on intentional acts designed to obtain money or benefits that a person is not legally entitled to.
Core Elements of Insurance Fraud
Although specific statutes vary, most insurance fraud cases share two core elements:
- Knowingly false or misleading information relating to an insurance transaction, such as a claim, application, or supporting documentation.
- Intent to defraud an insurer, policyholder, or other party by obtaining money, benefits, or coverage through deception.
Accidental errors or honest mistakes are generally not prosecuted as insurance fraud. The law focuses on deliberate schemes and purposeful misrepresentations.
Examples of Suspected Insurance Fraud
California regulations define “suspected insurance fraud” broadly to include a wide range of conduct. Common examples include:
- Submitting a claim for a loss or injury that never occurred.
- Overstating the value of damaged property or medical services.
- Failing to disclose pre-existing conditions or prior claims when required.
- Concealing relevant facts about how an accident happened.
- Manipulating addresses or garaging locations to obtain lower premiums than warranted.
Key California Statutes Governing Insurance Fraud
Insurance fraud in California is addressed through a mix of criminal and civil provisions, primarily:
Illinois Workplace Discrimination Claims Guide >
- California Penal Code sections 548, 549, 550, and 551 for criminal insurance fraud.
- California Insurance Code section 1871.7, known as the Insurance Frauds Prevention Act (IFPA), for civil enforcement and qui tam lawsuits.
- Insurance Code section 1875.20 and related regulations requiring insurers to maintain special investigative units (SIUs).
Criminal Insurance Fraud Under the Penal Code
Several Penal Code sections target different aspects of insurance fraud, particularly in the context of auto coverage.
| Statute | Conduct Covered |
|---|---|
| Penal Code § 548 | Intentionally damaging, abandoning, or disposing of a vehicle to submit a fraudulent insurance claim. |
| Penal Code § 549 | Referring individuals to repair shops or providers knowing they will file fraudulent auto insurance claims. |
| Penal Code § 550 | Submitting or preparing fraudulent claims, staging accidents, or presenting multiple claims for the same loss. |
| Penal Code § 551 | Prohibits certain referral fee arrangements between auto repair professionals and insurance agents. |
Penal Code § 550 is one of the most frequently used provisions and covers a broad range of fraudulent claim conduct, including false statements, false supporting documents, staged collisions, and duplicate claims for the same incident.
Civil Enforcement: California Insurance Frauds Prevention Act (IFPA)
The California Insurance Frauds Prevention Act, codified at Insurance Code § 1871.7, supplements criminal enforcement by allowing civil lawsuits against those who commit insurance fraud. Unlike many false claims laws, this statute is specifically tailored to fraud involving insurers, including private insurance companies.
Key features of the IFPA include:
- Coverage of fraud involving health, automotive, and workers’ compensation insurance.
- Authority for “any interested person” or insurer to file a civil action in the name of the State of California (a form of qui tam suit).
- No requirement that the government itself suffer financial loss for the action to proceed.
- Mandatory treble damages (three times the claimed amount) and civil penalties per violation.
Penalties for Insurance Fraud in California
California imposes both criminal and civil penalties for insurance fraud. Sanctions can include imprisonment, fines, restitution, and substantial civil damages.
Criminal Penalties
Insurance fraud is typically treated as a felony, though certain conduct may be charged as a misdemeanor depending on the amount involved and the defendant’s history.
- Felony insurance fraud can carry:
– Two, three, or five years in state prison.
– Fines up to $50,000, or up to double the amount of the fraud, whichever is greater.
– Possible additional prison time for prior insurance fraud convictions in auto-related cases. - Misdemeanor insurance fraud may involve:
– Up to six months to one year in county jail, depending on the charge.
– Fines that can reach $10,000 in some cases.
The California Department of Insurance emphasizes that insurance fraud is a felony offense punishable by up to five years in state prison and significant fines.
Civil Penalties and Damages
Under the Insurance Frauds Prevention Act, civil penalties and damages can be substantial. For each fraudulent claim, courts may impose:
- Civil penalties ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 per violation.
- Treble damages (three times the amount associated with each fraudulent claim), even if the claim was not ultimately paid.
The statute does not include an automatic reduction mechanism for damages, meaning courts must apply the prescribed treble damages structure when liability is established.
Special Investigative Units and Regulatory Requirements
California law does not rely solely on prosecution to combat insurance fraud. It also requires insurers themselves to actively investigate suspicious claims through dedicated special investigative units (SIUs).
Mandatory Fraud Units Within Insurers
Insurance Code § 1875.20 provides that every insurer admitted to do business in California must maintain a unit or division able to investigate possible fraudulent claims made by insureds or other parties seeking payment under a policy. These units are responsible for:
- Evaluating whether claim facts are consistent, reasonable, and supported by documentation.
- Identifying potential witnesses and conducting interviews.
- Collecting policy and claim information relevant to suspected fraud, such as claim numbers, policy details, dates of loss, and location of the incident.
- Preparing a synopsis of the facts supporting a reasonable belief that fraud has occurred.
Additional regulations under Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations further define “suspected insurance fraud” and outline the objectives of SIUs, emphasizing accurate documentation and timely referral of cases to authorities when warranted.
Reporting Suspected Insurance Fraud
California encourages both industry professionals and the general public to report suspected insurance fraud. The Fraud Division of the California Department of Insurance is the primary state entity responsible for investigating these reports.
How Consumers Can Report Fraud
Members of the public receive explicit protection when reporting suspected insurance fraud in good faith. Insurance Code § 1879.5 states that no person is subject to civil liability for filing a good faith report of suspected insurance fraud with the Department of Insurance.
Consumers can report suspected fraud by:
- Completing a Consumer Insurance Fraud Reporting Form and mailing it to the Enforcement Branch Headquarters Intake Unit.
- Calling the Department of Insurance’s Consumer Hotline, which routes information to the Fraud Division.
Industry Reporting Channels
Individuals working within the insurance industry—such as claims adjusters, agents, brokers, or SIU staff—use designated forms to report suspected fraud involving claims or agents:
- Using the FD-1 Suspected Fraudulent Claim referral form to report questionable claims.
- Contacting the Investigation Division when fraud is suspected involving agents or brokers.
Once a report is submitted, the Fraud Division may open an investigation, coordinate with law enforcement, and pursue criminal charges or refer civil actions when appropriate.
Impact of Insurance Fraud on Consumers and Insurers
Insurance fraud does not only affect insurers; it can also harm honest policyholders and the broader public. Fraudulent claims contribute to rising premium costs and can undermine trust in the insurance system.
- Higher premiums: Insurers may raise rates to offset losses from fraud, spreading costs across the entire pool of policyholders.
- Stricter claim review: Legitimate claimants may face more extensive documentation requests and longer processing times due to heightened fraud detection measures.
- Criminal exposure: Individuals who participate in seemingly minor fraud schemes—such as exaggerating a claim—risk serious criminal and civil consequences.
California’s legal framework aims to deter fraud through a combination of strong penalties and clear reporting mechanisms, while still protecting individuals who come forward with good-faith information.
Practical Tips to Avoid Involvement in Insurance Fraud
Understanding the law can help consumers and business owners avoid unintentionally stepping into fraudulent conduct.
- Be accurate and complete: Provide truthful, detailed information on all applications and claims, including prior losses and pre-existing conditions.
- Keep documentation: Retain copies of estimates, receipts, medical records, and correspondence with insurers.
- Reject suspicious offers: Decline any suggestion to exaggerate damages, stage incidents, or use providers known for questionable billing practices.
- Consult professionals: Seek legal or expert advice if you are unsure whether a claim scenario could be considered fraudulent.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Is all inaccurate information on an insurance claim treated as fraud?
No. California’s fraud laws focus on knowing misrepresentation combined with an intent to defraud. Honest mistakes or misunderstandings are generally distinguished from deliberate efforts to obtain unwarranted benefits.
Can insurance fraud be charged as a misdemeanor?
Yes. Some insurance fraud offenses, particularly those involving smaller dollar amounts, may be charged as misdemeanors and are sometimes referred to as “wobbler” offenses because they can be prosecuted as either misdemeanors or felonies.
Does the government have to lose money for a civil insurance fraud case under the IFPA?
No. Under the Insurance Frauds Prevention Act, it is not necessary that the government suffer harm as a result of the fraud. Civil actions may be based on losses to private insurers or policyholders.
What role do special investigative units (SIUs) play in the process?
SIUs are internal units within insurers mandated by law to investigate possible fraudulent claims, gather detailed information, and determine whether to refer cases to the Department of Insurance or law enforcement.
Are people protected from lawsuits when they report suspected fraud?
Yes. California Insurance Code § 1879.5 provides that individuals who file good faith reports of suspected insurance fraud with the Department of Insurance are not subject to civil liability for making those reports.
References
- Insurance Fraud is a Felony — California Department of Insurance. 2022-03-01. https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/105-type/95-guides/15-gen/insur-fraud-is-felony.cfm
- Reporting Fraud — California Department of Insurance. 2022-06-15. https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0300-fraud/reportingfraud.cfm
- California Insurance Fraud Prevention Act — Cotchett, Pitre & McCarthy LLP. 2021-11-10. https://www.cpmlegal.com/practices/Whistleblower-Qui-Tam-False-Claims-California/California-Insurance-Fraud-Prevention-Act
- California-SIU Requirement – State Insurance Code Section 1875.20 — Coalition Against Insurance Fraud. 2020-09-01. https://insurancefraud.org/regulations/california-siu-requirement-state-insurance-code-section-1875-20-california-code-of-regulations-subchapter-9-insurance-fraud-section-2698-30-et-seq/
- California Penal Code Sections 548, 549, 550 and 551 PC — Los Angeles Criminal Lawyer. 2022-01-20. https://www.losangelescriminallawyer.pro/california-penal-code-sections-548-549-550-and-551-pc-auto-insur.html
- Insurance Fraud — William Weinberg, Attorney at Law. 2021-05-18. https://www.williamweinberg.com/practice-areas/white-collar-crimes/fraud/insurance-fraud/
- Title 10, California Code of Regulations, Section 2698.30 — California Office of Administrative Law / Westlaw. 2019-10-01. https://govt.westlaw.com/calregs/Document/IE8CB040C5C2F11EC9C68000D3A7C4BC3
Similar Articles
Read full bio of Sneha Tete
