Hiring a Lawyer for Your Criminal Appeal

After a criminal conviction or harsh sentence, your next major decision is whether to seek an appeal and who should represent you in that process. Choosing the right appellate lawyer can significantly affect your chances of correcting legal errors, reducing your sentence, or even overturning your conviction.

Understanding What a Criminal Appeal Really Is

A criminal appeal is not a new trial. Instead of re-trying the facts, an appellate court reviews the existing record to decide whether the trial court committed legal errors serious enough to have affected the outcome.

Key Features of Criminal Appeals

• Focus on law, not facts: Appeals usually challenge how the law was applied, not whether witnesses were truthful.
• Based on the record: The appellate court relies on transcripts, motions, exhibits, and rulings from the trial; new evidence is rarely allowed.
• Written advocacy is central: The appellate brief, a detailed legal argument filed by your lawyer, is often the most important part of the case.
• Strict deadlines and rules: Appellate courts enforce tight timelines and technical filing requirements.

Common Grounds for Criminal Appeals

Not every loss at trial is appealable. Typical legal issues that may support an appeal include:

• Improper admission or exclusion of key evidence
• Incorrect jury instructions or legal standards
• Insufficient evidence to support the conviction
• Constitutional violations, such as infringement of the right to counsel or due process
• Sentencing errors or misapplication of sentencing guidelines

Your appellate lawyer’s first job is to study the record and identify which issues are strong enough to present to the appellate court.

Trial Lawyer vs. Appellate Lawyer: Why the Difference Matters

Many people assume the lawyer who handled their trial should also handle the appeal. In appellate practice, that is often not the best choice.

How Trial Practice Differs from Appellate Practice

Because appeals demand a different skill set, many commentators recommend hiring a lawyer who specializes in appellate work, particularly in criminal cases.

When You Should Consider Hiring an Appellate Lawyer

You should speak with an appellate lawyer promptly after a conviction or sentence, especially when:

• You believe the judge admitted or excluded evidence improperly.
• The jury instructions seemed confusing, incomplete, or contrary to your lawyer’s understanding of the law.
• You felt your trial lawyer’s performance was inadequate or seriously flawed.
• The sentence imposed appears far harsher than expected or inconsistent with similar cases.
• There were constitutional issues, such as unlawful searches, coerced statements, or denial of key defense rights.

Appeals are time-sensitive. Many jurisdictions impose short deadlines—sometimes 10 to 30 days—to file a notice of appeal. Missing that deadline can forfeit your right to direct review.

What an Appellate Lawyer Actually Does

An effective appellate lawyer performs several distinct functions aimed at uncovering legal error and presenting the strongest possible arguments on your behalf.

1. Reviewing the Trial Record

The lawyer will obtain and carefully examine:

• Trial transcripts (hearings, motions, and the full trial)
• Exhibits and physical evidence admitted at trial
• Pretrial motions and rulings, including suppression or evidentiary motions
• Jury instructions and verdict forms
• Sentencing memoranda and the sentencing transcript

During this review, the lawyer identifies potential errors and evaluates their impact on the verdict or sentence.

2. Conducting Legal Research

Next, the lawyer researches legal authorities that support your position, including:

• Prior decisions from the same appellate court or higher courts
• Relevant statutes, rules, and constitutional provisions
• Cases that show how similar errors have been treated on appeal

This research shapes which issues are raised and how arguments are framed.

3. Selecting the Strongest Issues

Good appellate advocacy often means leaving weak arguments out. Experienced appellate lawyers know that focusing on a few powerful issues can be more persuasive than presenting every possible complaint.

4. Drafting the Appellate Brief

The appellate brief is a comprehensive written argument that includes:

• A summary of the case and procedural history
• A concise statement of the issues presented for review
• Detailed legal arguments supported by citations to the record and precedent
• A specific request for relief, such as reversal, a new trial, or resentencing

In many appeals, judges decide the case largely based on the briefs, with oral argument playing a supporting role.

5. Presenting Oral Argument

Appellate courts do not always grant oral argument, but when they do, your lawyer will:

• Highlight the core issues and key legal authorities
• Answer judges’ questions and respond to concerns raised in the government’s brief
• Clarify misunderstandings in the record or law

6. Advising You After the Decision

After the court issues an opinion, the lawyer will explain:

• What the decision means for your conviction and sentence
• Whether further steps (such as rehearing or higher-level review) are realistic
• How the outcome interacts with any post-conviction or collateral remedies

How to Choose the Right Criminal Appellate Lawyer

Selecting appellate counsel should be an informed, deliberate process. Consider the following factors when evaluating candidates.

Specialization and Experience

• Criminal appeals focus: Look for a lawyer or firm that regularly handles criminal appeals rather than general practice or only trial work.
• Volume and type of appellate cases: Ask how many criminal appeals they have argued and whether they have experience with offenses similar to yours.
• Familiarity with your jurisdiction: Experience in the particular appellate court hearing your case can help, especially for local rules and practices.

Track Record and Reputation

• Past appellate outcomes (reversals, new trials, sentence reductions)
• Professional recognition or board certification in criminal or appellate law, where available
• Peer recommendations from other attorneys who know their appellate work

No lawyer can guarantee a win, but a strong record of favorable appellate results suggests reliable skill and judgment.

Legal Research and Writing Strength

Because written work is central, examine:

• Whether they are known for high-quality briefs or scholarly legal analysis
• How clearly they explain complex legal concepts when speaking with you
• Whether they can point to published decisions where their arguments shaped the law (if applicable)

Communication and Client Relationship

• Clarity: You should understand your options, risks, and likely timelines after speaking with the lawyer.
• Responsiveness: Reasonable availability to answer questions and provide updates.
• Transparency: Clear discussion of strategy, fees, and the limits of what an appeal can accomplish.

Fee Structure and Costs

Appellate work can be time-intensive, and fees vary widely based on complexity, record length, and the lawyer’s experience. Common arrangements include:

• Flat fees for the entire appeal up to a certain stage
• Hourly billing with an estimated range
• Additional costs for transcripts, filing fees, and experts (if needed)

Discuss all costs in advance and request a written fee agreement.

Working with Your Trial Lawyer

In some cases, it is beneficial for the appellate lawyer to:

• Consult with your trial lawyer to understand strategic choices made at trial
• Review whether trial counsel preserved errors for appeal through objections
• Coordinate future strategy if there is a possibility of retrial or resentencing

Questions to Ask Before You Hire an Appellate Lawyer

Use your initial consultation to gather specific information. Consider asking:

• How many criminal appeals have you handled, and in what courts?
• Have you worked on cases involving charges or issues similar to mine?
• What potential appellate issues do you see based on the information I’ve given you?
• What are the main strengths and weaknesses of my case on appeal?
• What kinds of outcomes are realistically possible (e.g., reversal, new trial, sentence reduction)?
• What is your fee structure, and what additional costs should I expect?
• How often will you update me, and how can I contact you with questions?

What to Expect from the Appeals Timeline

The appellate process typically unfolds in stages, often over many months:

1. Notice of appeal: A short filing that preserves your right to appeal; must be filed by a strict deadline.
2. Record preparation: Transcripts and documents from the trial court are compiled for the appellate court.
3. Briefing schedule: Your lawyer files an opening brief, the government responds, and your lawyer may file a reply.
4. Oral argument (if granted): Lawyers appear before a panel of judges to answer questions and emphasize key points.
5. Decision: The court issues a written opinion or order, which could affirm, reverse, modify, or remand the case.

Each jurisdiction has its own rules and timelines, so ask your lawyer for a realistic estimate based on local practice.

Frequently Asked Questions About Criminal Appeals

Q: Can an appeal introduce new evidence that was not used at trial?

A: Generally no. Appeals are usually limited to the existing trial record. New evidence is more often raised through separate post-conviction or collateral proceedings, which your appellate lawyer can advise you about.

Q: Is hiring a different lawyer for my appeal required?

A: It is not legally required, but many defendants choose a different lawyer because appellate advocacy requires distinct research and writing skills, and a new lawyer can provide a fresh, objective look at the case.

Q: What if I cannot afford a private appellate attorney?

A: In many jurisdictions, defendants who cannot afford counsel may qualify for a court-appointed lawyer on appeal. Ask the trial court or your current lawyer about eligibility and how to request appointed appellate counsel.

Q: How likely is it that an appeal will overturn my conviction?

A: The success rate for criminal appeals is generally modest, and many convictions are affirmed. However, a well-prepared appeal can still result in important relief, such as a new trial, corrected sentence, or clarification of legal rights.

Q: How long does a criminal appeal usually take?

A: Many appeals take several months to more than a year from the filing of the notice of appeal to the court’s decision, depending on the court’s workload, record size, and complexity of the issues.

Similar Articles

Teen Tobacco Purchase Laws: Age Limits Explained

Corporal Punishment Laws for Parents in America

Middle Fingers and Free Speech: When Is It Legal?

Underage Drinking in the U.S.: Legal Risks and Real-Life Consequences

Bullying and the Law: Rights, Rules, and School Responsibilities

Serving Alcohol Under 21: State Laws Guide

Author

medha deb

 

Medha Deb is an editor with a master's degree in Applied Linguistics from the University of Hyderabad. She believes that her qualification has helped her develop a deep understanding of language and its application in various contexts.

Read full bio of medha deb