Bigamy Laws in Virginia: Lessons From a Triple Marriage Case

Stories of people secretly marrying more than one spouse often sound like the plot of a television drama. Yet bigamy is a very real criminal offense, and courts in Virginia have not hesitated to prosecute when the facts warrant charges. The widely reported case of a man who married three times without properly ending his prior marriages offers a useful illustration of how these laws work and why seemingly personal relationship decisions can become serious criminal matters.

This article uses that triple-marriage scenario as a teaching tool to explain what bigamy is under Virginia law, how the crime is charged, the consequences of conviction, and practical issues such as forged marriage licenses and accidental bigamy. It is written for readers who want a deeper understanding of the legal rules without needing to wade through dense statutory language.

Understanding Bigamy: Core Legal Concepts

At its simplest, bigamy means entering into a new marriage while a prior marriage is still legally in effect. In legal terms, it is the act of a currently married person marrying another person during the lifetime of their existing spouse. While the concept is straightforward, the law surrounding bigamy deals with important nuances such as venue, intent, and the status of void marriages.

Basic Definition Under Virginia Law

Virginia’s bigamy statute provides that a person commits a crime if, while married to someone, they marry another person in the Commonwealth, or marry elsewhere and then live as spouses in Virginia. This captures both situations where the ceremony takes place inside Virginia and where the couple marries elsewhere but effectively establishes the relationship in the state.

• Currently married person: The accused must have an existing valid marriage that has not been legally dissolved.
• Subsequent marriage: The person then marries another individual, either in Virginia or elsewhere but subsequently cohabits with that person in Virginia.
• Living spouse: The original spouse must still be alive at the time of the later marriage.

As a result, no bigamy occurs if the prior marriage was properly terminated through divorce or annulment, or if the previous spouse has died before the new marriage is solemnized.

Bigamy as a Felony Offense

Bigamy is not treated as a minor technical violation in Virginia. The statute classifies it as a Class 4 felony, a category reserved for serious offenses that may involve substantial prison time. The felony status underscores the state’s view that circumventing the formal requirements of marriage and divorce is a significant breach of the law, not merely a private moral issue.

For comparison, other states also criminalize bigamy and treat it as a felony, often with sentencing ranges of several years in prison. While exact penalties differ by jurisdiction, this cross-state treatment confirms that bigamy is widely seen as an offense against the legal integrity of the marriage institution.

A Triple Marriage Scenario: How Bigamy Arises in Practice

The case that inspired this discussion involves a Virginia man who entered into three separate marriages over time without properly dealing with the legal status of his earlier unions. Prosecutors charged him with two counts of bigamy, along with counts of forgery for allegedly falsifying information on marriage license applications.

Although each case turns on its specific facts, this scenario helps illustrate common patterns:

• A person marries spouse A.
• Without obtaining a lawful divorce or annulment, the person marries spouse B.
• Later, still without dissolving the previous marriages, the person marries spouse C.
• To secure marriage licenses, the person may misrepresent being single or divorced.

From a legal perspective, such conduct can trigger multiple counts of bigamy, because each subsequent marriage during the lifetime of the original spouse constitutes a separate offense. When false statements appear on official documents, additional charges such as forgery may be added.

Forged Marriage Licenses and False Statements

Many jurisdictions require applicants for marriage licenses to provide information about their current marital status, including whether they are single, divorced, or widowed. In the triple-marriage case, prosecutors alleged that the defendant gave false information on these forms in order to obtain licenses, leading to forgery charges alongside bigamy.

Forgery generally involves creating or using a false document, or including false information, with intent to deceive. When the document is a marriage license, the forgery affects not only the parties involved but also public records and potentially property, inheritance, and support rights. Courts may see this as aggravating the seriousness of the underlying bigamy.

Void Marriages and Accidental Bigamy

A common question is whether someone can be prosecuted for bigamy when the second marriage is legally void from the outset. Virginia law treats certain marriages as “absolutely void”, including bigamous unions. That means the marriage has no legal effect and cannot produce marital rights such as equitable distribution or spousal support.

Bigamous Marriages as Legal Nullities

Virginia family law commentary explains that bigamous marriages are considered nullities: they are void and incapable of creating marital consequences. Courts have reinforced this principle in criminal cases as well. In one appellate decision, a defendant argued that because his subsequent marriage was void, he could not have “married another person” as required by the bigamy statute. The Court of Appeals rejected that argument and upheld the felony conviction.

This illustrates a crucial distinction:

• A bigamous marriage is legally void for purposes of family law rights.
• The act of entering into that void marriage may still be a criminal offense.

In other words, a void marriage does not shield a person from prosecution; it simply means the marriage has no legal effect in terms of property distribution, inheritance rights, or other marital benefits.

Accidental Bigamy: How It Can Happen

While some bigamy cases involve deliberate deception, others arise from misunderstanding or negligence. Family law practitioners note the phenomenon of accidental bigamy, typically occurring when an individual remarries too quickly, believing their prior divorce is final when it is not.

Examples include:

• Misreading a divorce decree or assuming verbal confirmation from a spouse means the divorce is complete.
• Failing to file required documents to finalize a divorce.
• Marrying in another jurisdiction without confirming the status of a pending case in Virginia.

Even in such cases, the second marriage may be void, and the legal untangling can be complex, especially when couples have mingled assets or had children together. Whether criminal charges are brought can depend on factors such as the person’s intent, the nature of any false statements, and prosecutorial discretion.

Penalties, Venue, and Prosecution Decisions

Because bigamy is a Class 4 felony in Virginia, defendants face substantial consequences if convicted. Understanding the potential penalties and where the case may be tried is important for anyone facing allegations or trying to avoid legal missteps.

Felony Classification and Sentencing

Virginia classifies bigamy as a Class 4 felony. While the precise sentencing range is governed by broader criminal statutes and guidelines, courts have described Class 4 felonies in this context as serious offenses that can carry multi-year prison sentences. A separate Virginia resource notes that bigamy, as a felony, is not subject to a statute of limitations, meaning prosecution can be initiated regardless of how long ago the alleged conduct occurred.

Potential consequences often include:

• Incarceration upon conviction, especially where conduct involves repeated offenses or related fraud.
• Felony record, which can affect voting rights, firearm ownership, and employment opportunities.
• Collateral consequences in family law matters, such as credibility problems in custody or support disputes.

Venue: Where Can Bigamy Be Prosecuted?

The bigamy statute addresses venue explicitly. A prosecution may be brought either in the locality where the subsequent marriage took place or the locality where the parties to the subsequent marriage cohabited. This gives prosecutors flexibility when deciding which jurisdiction is best suited to handle the case.

This approach ensures that Virginia courts can address conduct that affects residents and local records even when the ceremony itself took place in another jurisdiction.

Comparing Virginia’s Approach With Other Jurisdictions

While this article focuses on Virginia, a brief comparison with another state helps show that bigamy is broadly recognized as a felony offense in American law. For example, West Virginia’s statute declares that any person, being married, who marries another person during the life of their spouse—or marries elsewhere and then cohabits in West Virginia—is guilty of a felony punishable by one to five years in prison.

The structure of West Virginia’s law is similar to Virginia’s in key respects:

• Requirement of a prior, still-existing marriage.
• Coverage of marriages performed inside and outside the state.
• Felony classification with multi-year prison exposure.

These similarities underscore that bigamy is not a narrow, unusual offense; it is part of a broader pattern of protecting the legal integrity of marriage across U.S. jurisdictions.

Practical Guidance: Avoiding Bigamy and Related Legal Problems

The triple-marriage case demonstrates how quickly relationship decisions can lead to serious legal trouble when formal requirements are ignored. While this article is not legal advice, several practical steps can help individuals avoid bigamy and related crimes.

Key Preventive Measures

• Confirm divorce status in writing: Obtain certified copies of divorce decrees or annulment orders and verify that all required filings and waiting periods are complete before remarrying.
• Disclose marital history accurately: When applying for a marriage license, provide truthful information about prior marriages, divorces, and widowed status. False statements can support forgery or fraud charges.
• Consult a lawyer when unsure: If there is any doubt about whether a prior marriage was legally dissolved, seek legal advice from a family law or criminal defense attorney.
• Keep personal records organized: Maintain copies of marriage certificates, divorce decrees, and related court orders to avoid confusion later.
• Avoid “do-it-yourself” divorce shortcuts: Relying on informal agreements or believing that separation alone ends a marriage is dangerous; formal court action is usually required.

Frequently Asked Questions About Bigamy in Virginia

Key Takeaways From the Triple Marriage Case

The Virginia case involving three marriages and related forgery charges highlights several important lessons:

• Bigamy is a serious felony, not a minor paperwork issue.
• Void bigamous marriages can still form the basis of criminal convictions.
• False statements on marriage license applications may lead to forgery charges in addition to bigamy.
• Accidental bigamy can occur when divorces are not properly finalized, creating complex family and criminal law problems.
• Prosecutors may have multiple venue options, increasing flexibility in enforcement.

For individuals, the broader message is straightforward: treat marriage and divorce as legal events as much as personal ones. Ensuring that prior marriages are fully and formally dissolved before entering new ones is essential to avoid becoming the subject of a case like the triple-marriage prosecution.

Similar Articles

Your First Credit Card: How to Avoid Costly Fine‑Print Traps

Smart Student Borrowing: A Financial Literacy Guide

Brendlin v. California and the Fourth Amendment Passenger Rule

Miranda v. Arizona and the Birth of Modern Police Warnings

Bankruptcy Glossary: Plain-Language Guide To Common Terms Now

Understanding Bankruptcy Noticing in Federal Courts

Author

Sneha TeteBeauty & Lifestyle Writer

 

Sneha is a relationships and lifestyle writer with a strong foundation in applied linguistics and certified training in relationship coaching. She brings over five years of writing experience to waytolegal,  crafting thoughtful, research-driven content that empowers readers to build healthier relationships, boost emotional well-being, and embrace holistic living.

Read full bio of Sneha Tete